Reliability is usually a top priority when buying a new car. Yet, some vehicles end up causing more headaches than joy due to recurring issues that lead to costly repairs and, in some cases, lemon law claims. By examining data from 2024 on cars with high repair rates and everyday problems, we can make informed predictions about which models to approach cautiously in 2025.
Whether you’re considering an SUV, truck, or EV, knowing these potential pitfalls can help you make a more confident and informed choice in the new year.
What Makes a Car a “Lemon”?
Lemon laws vary by state, but generally, a “lemon” refers to a vehicle with significant defects that affect its safety, usability, or value. To qualify as a lemon, the defect must typically remain unresolved after several repair attempts or render the vehicle unusable for an extended time. Issues commonly leading to lemon law claims include chronic engine problems, electrical malfunctions, and transmission failures.
2024’s Most Problematic Vehicles: A Look at the Data
Using statistics from 2024, we can identify trends in vehicle models with high repair rates and joint complaints. Sources such as the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA), JD Power, and Consumer Reports provide data on vehicle reliability, consumer complaints, and repair frequency, allowing us to make data-driven predictions for 2025.
Some of the most common issues in 2024 included:
- Transmission Failures
- Engine Stalling or Misfiring
- Electrical System Malfunctions
- Brake System Issues
- Infotainment and Connectivity Failures
Based on these recurring issues, here are the vehicles that consumers may want to approach with caution in 2025.
Jeep Cherokee: Known for Transmission and Electrical Issues
The Jeep Cherokee has been plagued with transmission and electrical problems, especially in recent models. Owners report issues like rough shifting, transmission jerking, and frequent stalling, all of which affect drivability and safety. Electrical malfunctions, including problems with dashboard lights and infotainment systems, have also been widely documented.
Given these recurring issues, the Jeep Cherokee might continue to face similar complaints in 2025. Consumers looking at SUVs may want to explore alternative models to avoid these costly and inconvenient repairs.
Key Stats from 2024:
- Common Issues: Transmission failure, electrical malfunctions
- Complaints Filed: There is a high number of NHTSA complaints related to transmission and electrical systems
- Predicted Issues for 2025: Persistent transmission reliability concerns, dashboard malfunction, and rough shifting
Ford Explorer: Transmission and Engine Reliability Concerns
The Ford Explorer has a history of transmission and engine problems, with many 2024 models showing complaints about jerking, delayed shifting, and stalling. Many drivers have experienced engine failures at low mileage, an issue that can result in costly repairs or replacements.
This model’s historical reliability issues with these core components make it a vehicle to watch in 2025. While Ford has improved in some areas, ongoing complaints indicate that the Ford Explorer may still pose risks for consumers looking for a reliable SUV.
Key Stats from 2024:
- Common Issues: Transmission jerking, engine stalling, delayed shifting
- Complaints Filed: Notably high for engine and transmission problems
- Predicted Issues for 2025: Engine reliability, transmission shifting delays, stalling concerns
Chevrolet Silverado: Engine and Electrical Issues
Chevrolet’s Silverado has been a popular truck, but recent models have encountered significant issues with engine performance and electrical systems. Complaints include random stalling, excessive oil consumption, and intermittent electrical issues affecting lights and dashboard functions. If left unresolved, these problems can lead to expensive repairs.
Since engine and electrical issues were among the most common problems reported in 2024, the 2025 Silverado may continue to exhibit these concerns unless substantial improvements are made.
Key Stats from 2024:
• Common Issues: Engine stalling, electrical system malfunctions, excessive oil use
• Complaints Filed: High number of engine and electrical system complaints
• Predicted Issues for 2025: Persistent engine stalling, electrical glitches, oil consumption issues
Tesla Model S: Battery and Autopilot Issues
Tesla’s Model S has consistently innovated, but in 2024, there was an uptick in complaints regarding its battery life, Autopilot function, and infotainment system. Some owners have experienced battery degradation sooner than expected, which impacts range and charging frequency. Autopilot, a standout feature of the Model S, has also been prone to occasional malfunctions, leading to safety concerns.
If you’re considering a 2025 Model S, remember these recurring issues. Tesla has made strides in software updates, but certain mechanical aspects may continue to pose challenges, potentially leading to a lemon law claim.
Key Stats from 2024:
- Common Issues: Battery degradation, Autopilot malfunctions, infotainment glitches
- Complaints Filed: There are a significant number of complaints about battery performance and Autopilot functionality
- Predicted Issues for 2025: Battery reliability, Autopilot functionality, and ongoing infotainment issues
Volkswagen Atlas: Brake System and Electrical Problems
The Volkswagen Atlas has shown recurring issues with its brake system, such as premature brake wear and noise. Additionally, electrical system complaints in 2024 included problems with dashboard warnings and infotainment malfunctions. These issues can compromise safety, making the Atlas a potential candidate for lemon law claims.
As Volkswagen rolls out the 2025 model, consumers should monitor any updates to the Atlas’s brake and electrical systems to determine if these problems have been fully addressed.
Key Stats from 2024:
- Common Issues: Premature brake wear, electrical warnings, infotainment malfunctions
- Complaints Filed: High for brake and electrical problems
- Predicted Issues for 2025: Brake durability, electrical warnings, infotainment reliability
Hyundai Kona Electric: Charging and Battery Issues
Electric vehicles (EVs) are gaining popularity, but some models have faced unique reliability challenges. The Hyundai Kona Electric has been criticized for charging issues, including sudden drops in battery range and charging system malfunctions. In addition, some owners report persistent problems with regenerative braking and dashboard error messages.
If you’re considering an EV for 2025, the Hyundai Kona Electric’s reliability issues with its battery and charging system may warrant caution, especially if frequent long-distance travel is a priority.
Key Stats from 2024:
- Common Issues: Charging malfunctions, battery range inconsistencies, regenerative braking issues
- Complaints Filed: Significant for battery and charging issues
- Predicted Issues for 2025: Charging system reliability, battery degradation, regenerative braking concerns
What to Look for When Considering 2025 Models
If you’re set on purchasing a new 2025 model, there are some proactive steps you can take to avoid problematic vehicles:
Review Customer Complaints and Reliability Ratings
Always consult resources like the NHTSA, JD Power, and Consumer Reports for reliability ratings and customer feedback on specific models. High complaints can indicate recurring issues.
Pay Attention to Technical Service Bulletins (TSBs)
Manufacturers release TSBs to provide repair guidelines for recurring issues, even if a formal recall isn’t issued. Reviewing TSBs can give insight into common problems with specific models.
Consider Extended Warranties
If you choose a model known for repairs or recall history, investing in an extended warranty can provide added peace of mind. Ensure it covers critical systems prone to problems.
Stay Updated on Recalls and Software Updates
Manufacturers sometimes resolve issues through recalls or software updates, especially for infotainment and autonomous systems. Check for updates regularly to maintain your vehicle’s safety and reliability.
Final Thoughts: Make Informed Choices to Avoid a Lemon
While purchasing a new vehicle should provide reliability and peace of mind, some models have persistent issues that may lead to lemon law claims. By staying informed about the most problematic cars of 2024, you can avoid potential trouble in 2025. Whether you’re buying an SUV, truck, or EV, research, consider warranties, and read about other consumers’ experiences to choose a model with a strong track record for reliability.
